Vehicle repair
Compare Vehicle Repair Quotes
A quote comparison for a fictional 2017 hatchback car which has an intermittent starting fault; its cause is not confirmed. These quotations from three different automobile mechanics describe various diagnostic and repair assumptions.
Entirely fictional example. These synthetic offers are not like-for-like; no winner or savings calculation is implied. “Not stated” does not mean excluded.
01 / BRIEF COMPARISON SUMMARY
Cedar Lane Garage
Quotation summaryNorthway Auto Electrics
Quotation summary02 / comparison details
One criterion at a time.
Each stated value is supported by the synthetic excerpt shown for its supplier. “Not stated in this excerpt” describes only the excerpt, not the full document.
| Criterion | Bracken Motor WorksGenerated summary · interpretation The £680 estimate includes VAT, a battery test, diagnostic scan, replacement 12V battery and charging-output test. No starter-motor work is listed, but the excerpt does not establish whether the battery is the cause of the fault. The estimate remains valid for 21 days from its date. Timing, warranty, vehicle collection and payment terms are not stated; ask for test findings and how further work is approved. | Cedar Lane GarageGenerated summary · interpretation The £145 covers up to 1.5 hours of diagnostic inspection; parts and repairs will be priced only after diagnosis. The excerpt does not say whether VAT is included, whether the fee is credited, or what testing and collection are covered. Ask for findings, a repair estimate, approval limits and warranty terms before authorizing extra work. | Northway Auto ElectricsGenerated summary · interpretation The £1,240 estimate includes VAT for diagnosis and starter-motor replacement, with a battery test listed. A replacement battery or alternator is not listed, and the excerpt does not confirm the fault. Parts are said to have a 12-month warranty; labour warranty, collection and timing are not stated. Confirm assumptions and costs before proceeding. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price & tax | |||
| Stated amount | £680 estimate | £145 diagnostic fee; repairs priced later | £1,240 estimate |
| Tax basis | Including VAT | Not stated in this excerpt | Including VAT |
| Scope & specification | |||
| Diagnostic work | Battery test, diagnostic scan and charging-output test | Inspection up to 1.5 hours | Diagnosis listed; findings not supplied in this excerpt |
| Parts described | Replacement 12V battery supplied and fitted; starter motor not listed | Repair parts not priced until after diagnosis | Replacement starter motor; no replacement battery or alternator listed |
| Vehicle collection | Not stated in this excerpt | Not stated in this excerpt | Not stated in this excerpt |
| Work & responsibilities | |||
| Labour / testing | Fit and listed tests included | Testing scope not stated in this excerpt | Battery test included |
| Timing & terms | |||
| Warranty | Not stated in this excerpt | Not stated in this excerpt | 12 months for parts; labour warranty not stated |
| Timing / further-work approval | Completion timing and further-work approval process not stated in this excerpt | Appointment date to be confirmed; repair approval process not stated in this excerpt | Repair timing not stated; additional work requires approval |
| Offer validity | |||
| Validity period | 21 days | Not stated in this excerpt | Not stated in this excerpt |
Bracken Motor Works
The £680 estimate includes VAT, a battery test, diagnostic scan, replacement 12V battery and charging-output test. No starter-motor work is listed, but the excerpt does not establish whether the battery is the cause of the fault. The estimate remains valid for 21 days from its date. Timing, warranty, vehicle collection and payment terms are not stated; ask for test findings and how further work is approved.
Cedar Lane Garage
The £145 covers up to 1.5 hours of diagnostic inspection; parts and repairs will be priced only after diagnosis. The excerpt does not say whether VAT is included, whether the fee is credited, or what testing and collection are covered. Ask for findings, a repair estimate, approval limits and warranty terms before authorizing extra work.
Price & tax
Stated amount
Bracken Motor Works£680 estimate
Cedar Lane Garage£145 diagnostic fee; repairs priced later
Tax basis
Bracken Motor WorksIncluding VAT
Cedar Lane GarageNot stated in this excerpt
Scope & specification
Diagnostic work
Bracken Motor WorksBattery test, diagnostic scan and charging-output test
Cedar Lane GarageInspection up to 1.5 hours
Parts described
Bracken Motor WorksReplacement 12V battery supplied and fitted; starter motor not listed
Cedar Lane GarageRepair parts not priced until after diagnosis
Vehicle collection
Bracken Motor WorksNot stated in this excerpt
Cedar Lane GarageNot stated in this excerpt
Work & responsibilities
Labour / testing
Bracken Motor WorksFit and listed tests included
Cedar Lane GarageTesting scope not stated in this excerpt
Timing & terms
Warranty
Bracken Motor WorksNot stated in this excerpt
Cedar Lane GarageNot stated in this excerpt
Timing / further-work approval
Bracken Motor WorksCompletion timing and further-work approval process not stated in this excerpt
Cedar Lane GarageAppointment date to be confirmed; repair approval process not stated in this excerpt
Offer validity
Validity period
Bracken Motor Works21 days
Cedar Lane GarageNot stated in this excerpt
03 / questions to ask
What to clarify next.
Bracken Motor Works
What test results support the proposed battery replacement?
What are the repair timing, collection and parts or labour warranty terms?
Cedar Lane Garage
What tests are included in the 1.5-hour diagnostic inspection?
Is the diagnostic fee credited, and will repairs wait for written approval?
Northway Auto Electrics
What findings support the starter-motor work, and what is covered by its warranty?
What labour warranty, completion timing and collection options apply?
04 / offer summaries
Three supplier proposals.
Fictional report
Preview the PDF report
If the PDF preview does not appear in your browser, open the PDF in a new tab above or download the fictional report.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I compare a vehicle diagnosis with a repair quote?
Check whether each amount covers diagnostic testing, the proposed repair, or both. Ask what findings support the recommended work and whether any diagnostic fee is credited if you proceed. A diagnosis or estimate is not confirmation that every proposed repair is necessary.
What parts and labour details should a repair quote include?
Look for the parts being fitted, whether they are new or another stated type, the labour charged and any separate diagnostic or shop fees. Ask the garage to identify details that are not stated and to explain how the amount may change if the initial estimate is revised.
Should I approve extra work before it is done?
Agree how the garage will contact you if inspection identifies additional work. Ask for the findings and revised price, set any approval limit you are comfortable with, and make clear that work beyond the agreed scope needs your approval first.
Which testing, warranty and collection terms should I check?
Confirm what checks or road tests are included, the expected completion and collection arrangements, and what parts and labour warranty terms apply. Read the full terms and ask the garage to clarify any conditions or limits before authorising the repair.
Your documents stay private
